Here's the pattern every ecommerce marketer knows: December hits, revenue spikes, champagne flows. January arrives, and those eager holiday shoppers? Gone. Vanished. Like they never existed.
You acquired them at premium CPAs during the most competitive shopping season of the year. They bought once, maybe twice. Then silence.
The real money isn't in that first December purchase. It's in February, May, and September when they come back without you spending another dollar on acquisition. But that only happens if you actually have a plan for the week after they buy.
Most brands don't. They send a shipping confirmation, maybe a review request, then... nothing until the next promotional blast. Which gets ignored because there's no relationship there.
Let's fix that.
Why December Buyers Are Different (And Why That Matters)
December customers aren't your typical buyers. About 40% of them are gift-givers who've never used your product themselves. Another chunk bought on impulse during a flash sale. They don't have the same investment in your brand as someone who sought you out in March.
This isn't a problem. It's just reality.
What it means: your post-purchase sequence needs to do the relationship-building work that normally happens before someone buys. You're working backwards, and that requires a different approach than your standard "thanks for buying, here's 10% off your next order" email.
The window is tight. Research from Klaviyo shows that if a December buyer doesn't engage with your brand by mid-February, the likelihood of a second purchase drops by 70%. You've got about six weeks to make them care.
No pressure.
Sequence 1: The Product Education Series (Days 3-14)
Trigger: 3 days after delivery confirmation
Why it works: They have your product. Now make sure they actually use it.
This isn't about selling. It's about preventing buyer's remorse and returns. Send 3-4 emails focused entirely on getting value from what they bought:
- Email 1: Quick start guide ("Get the most out of your [product] in the first week")
- Email 2: Common mistakes to avoid (people love learning what NOT to do)
- Email 3: Advanced tips or unexpected uses
- Email 4: Customer success stories with the same product
Glossier does this brilliantly. Buy a skincare product in December, and you'll get a detailed email about application techniques, layering order, and what results to expect when. Not a single promotional message. Just useful information that makes you more likely to see results, love the product, and buy again.
The key is specificity. Generic "check out our blog" emails get ignored. "Here's how to avoid the 3 mistakes that ruin [specific product]" gets opened.
Sequence 2: The Gift-Giver Follow-Up (Days 7-21)
Trigger: Purchase during November-December + gift message detected OR shipped to different address than billing
Why it works: The person who bought isn't the person using it.
This sequence has two tracks:
To the buyer: "Hope they loved it! Here's what makes a great companion gift" (suggest complementary products for next occasion)
To the recipient: This is trickier because you might not have their email. If you do (from account creation or gift registry), send a gentle introduction: "[Name] thought you'd love this. Here's how to get started."
If you don't have the recipient's email, include a card in the package with a QR code to a personalized landing page. Offer something valuable (not just a discount) for signing up—extended warranty, exclusive content, community access.
Allbirds includes a simple card: "This was a gift? Create an account to track your impact and get care instructions." Low-pressure, value-focused. It works.
About 15-20% of gift recipients will engage if you make it easy and worthwhile. That's 15-20% who would otherwise never be in your ecosystem.
Sequence 3: The Engagement Reactivation (Days 14-30)
Trigger: No email opens or site visits since purchase
Why it works: They're drifting away. Pull them back before they're gone.
Forget the discount. Seriously. If the first thing you do when someone ignores you is offer them money, you're training them to ignore you until you get desperate.
Instead, try these angles:
- "We noticed you haven't opened your [product]" (if you have that data)
- "Quick question about your order" (curiosity-driven subject line)
- "Is everything okay with your [product]?" (concern, not sales)
- "You're missing out on [specific valuable thing]" (exclusive content, community, etc.)
The goal is a single action: get them to click. Once they're back on your site or engaging with content, the algorithm gods smile upon you and your future emails are more likely to land in the primary inbox.
Patagonia sends repair guides and sustainability impact reports to non-engaged customers. Not promotional. Just "here's something you might care about based on what you bought." It repositions the brand relationship from transactional to value-aligned.
Sequence 4: The Replenishment Reminder (Days 30-90)
Trigger: Purchase of consumable product + typical usage timeline
Why it works: They need to buy again anyway. Be there when they realize it.
This only works if you're selling something that runs out. Skincare, supplements, coffee, pet food, printer ink (the original subscription trap).
The timing is everything. Send too early and you're annoying. Too late and they've already reordered from a competitor or forgotten about you entirely.
Do the math on your product:
- 30-day supply? Email at day 25.
- 60-day supply? Email at day 50, again at day 65.
- 90-day supply? Email at day 75, day 85, day 95.
Ritual (the vitamin company) absolutely nails this. Their emails aren't pushy—they're helpful: "You're probably running low. Want us to send your next bottle?" One-click reorder. Frictionless.
Add a small incentive for setting up a subscription (10% off, free shipping, early access to new products), but make the one-time reorder option equally easy. Some people will never subscribe, and that's fine. A repeat purchase is still a win.
Sequence 5: The Category Expansion (Days 30-60)
Trigger: 30 days after first purchase + engagement with at least 2 emails
Why it works: They know you now. Introduce them to what else you offer.
This is where you can actually sell, but do it intelligently. Don't blast your entire catalog. Recommend based on what they bought:
- Bought running shoes? Show them running socks, not basketball gear.
- Bought a coffee maker? Show them beans and filters, not tea kettles.
- Bought skincare? Show them the next step in the routine, not makeup.
Amazon's "frequently bought together" exists because it works. But most brands just send "NEW ARRIVALS!" emails that have nothing to do with the customer's interests.
Warby Parker does this well. Buy glasses, and a few weeks later you'll get an email about blue light lenses or contact lenses—logical extensions of vision care, not random products.
Structure it as education: "You loved [product]. Here's what customers typically add next." Social proof + relevance = higher conversion than generic promotions.
Sequence 6: The VIP Invitation (Days 45-60)
Trigger: First purchase + email engagement above 40% + no second purchase yet
Why it works: They're interested but haven't committed. Give them a reason to feel special.
Create an exclusive segment for engaged first-time buyers. Offer something that feels like recognition, not desperation:
- Early access to new products or sales
- Invitation to a private community or Facebook group
- Exclusive content (behind-the-scenes, founder Q&A, expert interviews)
- Special loyalty program tier
- Birthday club or anniversary perks
The psychology here is identity. You're not just selling products—you're offering membership in something. People want to belong, especially to things that feel selective.
Sephora's Beauty Insider program is the gold standard. That first purchase gets you in the door, and suddenly you're tracking points, unlocking tiers, and getting birthday gifts. The program itself becomes a reason to keep buying.
Your version doesn't need to be that complex. Even a simple "You're now part of our inner circle—here's what that means" email with tangible benefits can shift the relationship.
Sequence 7: The Win-Back Campaign (Days 75-90)
Trigger: No second purchase by day 75 + declining email engagement
Why it works: Last chance before they're lost forever.
This is your Hail Mary. You've tried education, engagement, and invitation. Now it's time to be direct.
Three-email sequence:
Email 1 (Day 75): "We miss you" angle. Genuine, not guilt-trippy. "It's been a while since your order. Everything okay? Here's what's new."
Email 2 (Day 82): Social proof. "Here's what customers like you are loving right now." Show bestsellers, reviews, user-generated content.
Email 3 (Day 90): The offer. Now you can use a discount, but make it meaningful (20%+ or free shipping threshold). This is your last shot—make it worth their while.
If they don't bite after this sequence, move them to a quarterly re-engagement campaign and focus your energy on better prospects. Not everyone will convert, and that's fine. Better to know at day 90 than keep spending resources on dead ends.
Everlane's win-back emails are refreshingly honest: "We noticed you haven't shopped in a while. Here's 20% off to come back." No manipulation, just a straightforward offer. Sometimes that's all you need.
The Technical Setup (Because This Only Works If It Actually Runs)
Look, these sequences sound great in theory. In practice, you need the infrastructure to actually execute them. Here's what that looks like:
Minimum requirements:
- ESP with automation capabilities (Klaviyo, Drip, Omnisend for ecommerce)
- Proper event tracking (purchase, delivery, page views, email engagement)
- Segmentation ability (first-time buyers, gift purchases, product categories)
- Dynamic content blocks (so you're not building 50 versions of the same email)
Nice to have:
- Predictive analytics for replenishment timing
- AI-powered send-time optimization
- Advanced personalization (beyond just first name)
- Cross-channel coordination (email + SMS + push)
You don't need the fancy stuff to start. Basic automation with good segmentation beats perfect personalization that never launches.
Set up one sequence at a time. Get it working, measure results, then add the next one. Trying to build all seven at once is how you end up with none of them running by February.
What Success Actually Looks Like
Metrics that matter for these sequences:
Engagement metrics:
- Open rates (aim for 25-35% for post-purchase emails)
- Click rates (8-12% is solid)
- Unsubscribe rates (under 0.5% means you're not being too aggressive)
Business metrics:
- Repeat purchase rate from December cohort (benchmark: 25-30% by March)
- Time to second purchase (faster is better—under 60 days is ideal)
- Customer lifetime value of sequenced vs. non-sequenced buyers (should be 40-60% higher)
- Email-attributed revenue from automation (should be 20-30% of total email revenue)
A client in the supplement space implemented these sequences last January. Their December 2024 buyer cohort had a 34% repeat purchase rate by March, compared to 18% the previous year. The difference? These automated sequences running in the background while their team focused on acquisition.
That's an extra 16% of customers who bought again without additional ad spend. At their average order value of $67, that's meaningful money.
The Part Nobody Talks About: Maintenance
You'll build these sequences once and they'll run forever, right?
Not quite.
Plan to review and update quarterly:
- Refresh creative (people notice when you're sending the same email from 2023)
- Update product recommendations (discontinue old products, add new ones)
- Adjust timing based on actual customer behavior (maybe your replenishment window is 35 days, not 30)
- Test new subject lines and content approaches
- Remove what's not working (if an email consistently underperforms, kill it or fix it)
Set a calendar reminder for March, June, September, and December. Spend 2-3 hours reviewing performance and making updates. That's all it takes to keep these sequences effective.
The brands that win at retention treat their automated sequences like products, not set-it-and-forget-it campaigns. They iterate, improve, and optimize continuously.
Start Here
If you're reading this in November 2025, you have time to set this up before the holiday rush. If you're reading it in January, you're probably panicking a bit. That's okay.
Start with Sequence 1 (Product Education) and Sequence 4 (Replenishment). Those two alone will move the needle on repeat purchases. Add the others as you have capacity.
The December buyers you're about to acquire are expensive. Make them worth it by actually keeping them around.
Your future self in Q2, looking at healthy repeat purchase rates instead of scrambling for new acquisition, will thank you.
Top comments (0)